mpemba

hot or cold, who freezes first?

Does hot water freeze before cold water? Sometimes, by chance. And never more than half the time, unless the containers are unfair or the water remembers being hot.

Physics
Probability
Python
NumPy

The question

In 1963 a Tanzanian schoolboy, Erasto Mpemba, noticed that his ice cream mix froze faster when he put it in the freezer hot. He published the observation with the physicist Denis Osborne in 1969, and it has carried his name since. Aristotle, Bacon and Descartes had remarked on something similar. Sixty years of experiments have proposed evaporation, dissolved gas, convection and frost as causes, and careful measurements have since cleared most of them away. Burridge and Linden found no evidence that hot water cools to 0 °C any faster than cold water.

What survives in ordinary water is supercooling. Water usually cools well below 0 °C before it freezes, and the moment the first ice crystal forms is random. If that is the whole story, a single race between a hot cup and a cold one says very little. The thing to measure is a probability: how often the hot cup freezes first. This project asks what can be said about that number in general, and what it looks like under the best current model of nucleation.

The lottery

The model is Klimov and Finkelstein's. A cup cools by Newton's law towards the freezer temperature, and ice then nucleates as a random event whose rate climbs extremely steeply with supercooling: at about 7 K below freezing the wait is minutes, at 6 K it is weeks. Run it below. One race is a coin with a bias you cannot see. A thousand races show the bias.

The lottery · race them yourself
A hot and a cold cup go into the same freezer. Which one freezes first?
hot, 70 °C
cold, 20 °C
0°20°40°60°freezer -7.00 °C0 °C, ice is possible below herepress race0time →
containers
rough one
—
hot first 0 of 0
Each cup cools by Newton's law and then waits, supercooled, for its first ice crystal, which arrives at a random moment that depends steeply on how cold it is. With no rough container, the cups are drawn from the same population and handed out at random, and the hot-first rate settles at or under one half whatever you set. Give the rough container (1 K easier to nucleate) to a random cup and it still stays under. Give it to the hot cup every time and the rate goes well past one half, which is how the published records above one half were made. The model and its parameters are Klimov and Finkelstein's, as in the paper.

Why one half is a ceiling

On its way down, the hot cup has to pass through the temperature the cold cup started at. Suppose heating leaves nothing behind, so that from that moment the hot cup behaves like a cold cup that started late. Suppose too that the two containers are interchangeable, for instance identical cups handed out at random. Then from the crossing point the race is between two equally matched contestants, one of which has a head start, and the hot cup wins at most half the time.

The argument uses no cooling law and no model of nucleation, and it survives every cup having its own random cooling rate. So a hot-first rate above one half, in a fair design, means heating changed something other than the temperature: water lost to evaporation, gas driven out, or frost melted under a hot tin so that it sits better on the shelf. In a design where the containers differ on purpose, a rate above one half needs no memory at all.

A window half a kelvin wide

Under the model the probability also has a floor, set by one number. Call Da the nucleation rate at the freezer temperature divided by the cooling rate. When Da is small, ice forms long after both cups have settled at the freezer temperature, and the hot cup wins nearly half the time. When Da is large, ice forms while the cups are still cooling, and the cold cup almost always gets there first. The effect lives around Da = 1, which for these parameters is 6.95 K of supercooling. Da changes by a factor of e for every 0.12 K, so the whole visible effect fits inside about 0.56 K of freezer temperature. A bigger cup moves the window only slightly: to 6.60 K for 35 mL and 6.25 K for a litre.

The window · 70 °C against 20 °C
Identical containers see the effect only in a band about half a kelvin wide
identical containers
containers that differ
0.00.10.20.30.40.5-6.5-7.0-7.5-8.0freezer temperature, °C (colder →)ceiling ½0.3 K0.5 K1 K
Da
1.52
P(hot first)
0.218
floor
0.101
mean wait at freezer temp
11 min

with differing containers here: 0.3 K → 0.36 · 0.5 K → 0.40 · 1 K → 0.43

Drag along the freezer temperature. The black curve is the exact probability for identical containers, the dotted grey line under it is the power-law floor, and the dashed line at one half is the ceiling. The grey curves give each container its own nucleation temperature (spread 0.3, 0.5 or 1 K) and cooling rate. They spread the effect across several kelvin but never cross one half, because the containers are still assigned at random. Computed with the paper's code; the grey curves average 2,000 container pairs each, so they carry about ±0.01 of sampling noise.

Real containers differ by more than that. Different tubes nucleate at different temperatures, typically by half a kelvin to a kelvin, and Brownridge's vials by several. With a spread of 0.5 to 1 K the window stretches across several kelvin, and at −7.5 °C the hot cup wins about 27 to 37 percent of the time, where identical containers would give 0.4 percent. Where the effect shows up depends mostly on how much the containers differ, and only secondarily on water.

What the experiments show

Read against the ceiling, the published record sorts itself. Every hot-first rate above one half comes from a design in which the containers were not interchangeable, and the designs that come close to fair all report rates below one half.

StudyContainersHot first
Brownridge 2011a pair of vials picked because their freezing points differ by about 5.5 °C28 / 28
Burridge & Hallstadius 2020one beaker sanded inside, on purpose7 / 9 in the rough one, 0 / 7 in the smooth
Klimov & Finkelstein 2025closed vials, roughly fairabout a third near −7 °C
Janni et al. 2026tins and beakers, random placement46 / 176 samples
Burridge & Linden 2016fair0 / 3

Burridge and Hallstadius published their raw time series, which allow a sharper count than their paper gives. Over every pairing of a rough and a smooth beaker, whatever the starting temperatures, the rough beaker froze first in 18 of 20. The container decided the race and the starting temperature did not.

Janni, Botero Ampudia and Dahlberg have the largest recent data set, 176 samples in five setups. Simulating their exact protocol with no memory at all reproduces some setups and not others. The one that stands out is the only setup where tins stood on a metal baking sheet: 21 hot-first counts against a no-memory interval of 3 to 12. That fits a candidate for memory first raised in a 1969 letter to New Scientist: a hot tin melts the frost beneath it and improves its own contact with the cold. Their summary statistics cannot settle it, so for now it is a hypothesis that needs their per-sample data.

Where it stands

The paper is in draft, written for the American Journal of Physics. The per-sample data from Janni et al. have been requested, and the setup on the metal sheet will be tested directly if they arrive. The experiment that would settle the memory question is cheap: freeze the same sealed tube many times after hot and cold pre-treatment, in random order, so each container is only ever compared with itself. A home version is designed and has not been run yet.

Both figures run the paper's model. The race is a browser port that reproduces the paper's exact probabilities (0.392 at −6.8 °C, 0.218 at −7.0 °C, 0.067 at −7.2 °C) to within sampling error; the window is computed by the paper's own Python.